You're here: My Music Blogging » Indie Music » Article: New Yorker: Indie rock too white

New Yorker: Indie rock too white

budiputra — October 20, 2007 / 10:33 pm

Sean Nelson wrote an interesting post about the concept (and history) of indie rock:

Sasha Frere-Jones of the self-hyped funk band, Ui, attempts to take to task the apparent “whiteness” of today’s indie rock and understand how it came to be in his New Yorker article, “A Paler Shade of White.” The first sign that things might be a little off is in his analysis of the origins of indie rock: “The indie genre emerged in the early eighties, in the wake of British bands such as the Clash and Public Image Ltd.” Nevermind that The Clash was originally signed to CBS Records, aka Columbia, or that indie isn’t really a genre - It just means all the music associated with being outside of the major labels, which just happens to be most music. Or that his lamentation of the death of rhythm is easily upended by Deerhoof. Or that The Field’s “From Here We Go Sublime” is composed entirely out of The Flamingo’s “I Only Have Eyes for You.” Read it if you want to laugh at some misplaced Sufjan Stevens references (who, by the way, makes about a thousand references to black folk music on his albums), and a conclusion that sees racial equality as the cause of indie segregation.

Source

Post to: delicious, Digg, ma.gnolia, Stumbleupon

Ikuti diskusi Satu komentar untuk artikel ini.

  1. sixteenhole.com

    Pembahasannya matang dan mendidik! sukses untuk mumusicblogging!

    All The Best,
    Igoy Cavalera
    http://www.sixteenhole.com (Indie Music Network)

    July 16th, 2008 at 1:55 am

Ikuti diskusi, tuliskan komentar Anda.

LOCAL SEARCH

Search only in this blog

GLOBAL SEARCH

Search across Asia Blogging Network

GLOBAL

CHANNEL

COLUMN

More? Go to Asia Blogging Network Column section.

FEATURED

COMMENT

  • » Mimpi Anggun di Surabaya Tidak Jadi Kenyataan ~ Blog Archive ~ Musik Indonesia (Asia Blogging Network) — [...] Keinginan Anggun agar penonton yang datang ke konsernya tidak asyik foto-foto dengan ponsel ternyata hanya cukup jadi mimpi saja. ...
  • SHEMY — i love u all, power slaVES.BANGKITLAH KEMBALI.VANS WONOSOBO.KAPAN KONSER DI WONOSOBO...?
  • arie — ne emang berita keren.secara gue ngefans banget ma HEYDI IBRAHIM.
  • ridwn — hah gua suka maen bola
  • supratman — aq mohon bgt please indonesian idol 2009 kpan di bka lgi aq pgn bgt mncoba jd penyanyi indonesi/jd orang trknl........ mdah2an ...
  • supratman — waduh aq dah gx sabar nich kpan ya indonesian idol di bka lg??????????? aq pgn cpet manggung nich........ please jgn tutup dulu ...
  • vad — wahhhh kerennn ... hemm warna rock yg jadi gimana yahhh ...!!! di tunggu albumnya..... pokoe.. maju terus rock indonesia........!!
  • Bagus mulyana — Bravolah bwt Idol mh,,, Ttp smngat yUkk,,,!!
  • Alie Fivers — Riichie . . . Xm kug cAkep bgd sIch . . suuksses dah bwt FM
  • ICHWAN LUTHFI — allo diMAna ya aq biSA dapet'n lgu" Ost namaku dick,, yg judulx The One?........... please ........... soal nya tu lagu enak bnget di ...